Project Sign's "Estimate of the Situation"
By ATCT Editorial Team · Published · updated
The account
Air Force investigators supposedly wrote a secret report in 1948 concluding that flying saucers came from another planet.
What investigators found
The document is known through Edward Ruppelt's account; according to him, the top brass rejected its conclusion and the copies were destroyed, and none has surfaced to this day.
The story
In 1948, the Project Sign team, the Air Force's first official study of flying saucers, was working at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base in Ohio. According to Edward Ruppelt, who later headed Project Blue Book, some of the investigators drafted a document called the "Estimate of the Situation," which pointed to an interplanetary origin as the best explanation for cases such as that of pilots Chiles and Whitted.
According to Ruppelt, Air Force Chief of Staff General Hoyt Vandenberg rejected the report for lack of proof, and the copies were eventually destroyed. No copy has been found in the released archives, and its content is known only through secondhand accounts. For some, the episode marks the Air Force's turn toward a more skeptical stance; for others, the document was never as conclusive as the story goes.